Skip to content
Slotora CoursesStart selling your course

Giving feedback on photos of students' work in a mentored course

At the desk you correct a student by watching her work. Online you see the result, in a few photos, after she has finished. That is less than you are used to — but with the right task and the right kind of answer, it is enough to teach well.

What a photo can and cannot show

Start by being honest with yourself about what you can judge from a picture. A good photo shows shape, symmetry and proportion; the smile line and the free edge; coverage and evenness of colour; lash direction, spacing and mapping; brow shape and balance between the two sides. A photo shows almost nothing about adhesion, retention, heat, how long the work took or how the client felt. Thickness and the apex show only from the side, and only if the student photographs the side.

So the first job of feedback happens before the student picks up her phone: the task has to ask for photos that show what you need to judge.

Write the task so the photos can be judged

On a mentored course on Slotora, a lesson can carry a task. The student hands in her work as a short note and up to four photos, so the task should say which four. Name the angles the way you would check the work in person.

  • For a nail overlay: from above, all five nails; one nail from the side to show the apex; the cuticle area close up; the free edge looking down the nail to show the curve.
  • For a lash set: eyes closed from straight in front; from above, looking down the lash line; from the side; eyes open.
  • For brows: straight on with both brows in the frame; each brow from a slight angle; the mapping before the work, if mapping is the lesson.

Add the conditions: daylight or a daylight lamp, no filter, a plain background, the camera close enough for the work to fill most of the frame and far enough to stay sharp. Students who have read the close-up guide already know the trick of locking focus on the work; it helps here too.

Then ask for a sentence or two of her own. “What do you think went well, and what would you change?” takes her a minute, tells you whether she can see her own mistakes, and often answers your question about what the photo cannot show — “the third nail lifted the next day”, “the model’s eyes watered”.

Decide what you are looking for, before you look

Write down, for each task, the handful of things a good result has. For a classic set it might be: correct isolation, extensions following the natural direction, an even map, a clean base, no lashes stuck together. This short list is your rubric. It keeps your answers consistent from the first student to the fiftieth, it stops a strong photo of one thing distracting you from a problem with another, and it makes it easier to explain why you asked for another attempt.

The shape of a good answer

Your answer is written, and students read written feedback more literally than spoken feedback. A structure helps both of you.

One specific strength. Not “lovely work”, but what is right and why: “Your smile line is even across all five nails — that is the hardest part of this lesson.” A specific strength tells her what to keep doing.

The one or two fixes that matter most. You will usually see more than two things. Choose the ones that would change the result most, or that would cause a problem on a client, and leave the rest for later attempts. A list of nine corrections teaches nothing; two clear ones get fixed.

How to fix them. Say what to do differently, in terms of her hands: “hold the brush flatter as you reach the sidewall”, “isolate further from the root before you attach”. Point her to the lesson and the moment in it where you show the step.

What to send next. End with the next action: try again and hand in the same angles, move on to the next lesson, or practise one step several times before the next full attempt.

Describe the work, not the student

“The apex sits too far forward” is about the nail. “You always rush the apex” is about her. The first is easy to act on and hard to take personally; the second is the reverse. Keep every sentence about what is in the photo, and you can be completely direct without being unkind.

Say plainly when you cannot judge something. “From these photos I can’t tell whether the base is thin enough — next time, add one from the side” is more useful than a guess, and it teaches her what to look for.

Feedback that builds over attempts

A student on a mentored course hands in work more than once, and your answers should read as a sequence, not as separate verdicts. Before you answer, look at what you told her last time. If she fixed what you asked for, say so first and specifically — “the apex is where it should be now” — before anything new. If she did not, ask whether the instruction was clear before you repeat it more firmly; the same correction in the same words rarely works twice.

Move the bar as she improves. On a first attempt, the right fixes are the big ones: shape, placement, safety. Once those are steady, your answers can turn to finish and speed, the things that separate good work from work a client books again. Telling a beginner about finish while her shape is still wrong only spreads her attention thinner.

Know when to say “ready”. Part of what a student pays a mentor for is the moment someone she trusts tells her the work is right. When it is, say so plainly and without hedging, and say what the next stage is.

When you see something unsafe

Occasionally a photo shows more than technique: signs of overfiling, lashes bonded together at the base, skin that looks irritated. Say so clearly and early in your answer, tell her to stop that practice until it is sorted, and send her to the right person — the product’s manufacturer, a pharmacist, a doctor — rather than diagnosing from a picture. Your course is about technique; her model’s health is not something a photo lets you judge.

Keeping up with the queue

Everything students hand in on a mentored course arrives in one queue of waiting work, and you answer from there. Mentoring is the most valuable part of such a course and the part that takes your time, so plan it.

  • Say in the course description how long students should expect to wait for an answer, and keep to it.
  • Set aside regular time for the queue rather than answering in the gaps between clients.
  • Keep your own notes of the explanations you give most often, then tailor them for each student — a pasted paragraph that does not match her photo is worse than a short personal answer.
  • When the same fault appears in many submissions, the lesson needs improving. Add a sentence to its text or film the step again.

Mentored, not video

Tasks belong to mentored courses. On Slotora a video course cannot carry a lesson task; if you want to answer students’ work, choose the mentored type when you create the course. If you are deciding between the types, the guide to moving a workshop online compares them, and quizzes that test practical knowledge covers the other way of checking understanding, which works on every course type.

Teach with your eye on the work

Set tasks, receive students’ photos in one queue and answer each one in writing.

Read next